Washington is weighing changes that could shrink your benefits and delay your retirement. Here's how we got here, and what lawmakers aren't telling you.
As you read these words, your representatives are gearing up for a fight over Social Security. Behind closed doors, they’re wrestling with decisions that could affect all of us for decades to come.
Many hope you’re binging on Netflix instead.
Congress is entering its lame-duck session, that weird stretch between the November election and January when politicians still have all their power but, in some cases, little left to lose.
Some are retiring; others are on their way out. A new Congress is waiting in the wings. Before the seats change hands, there’s a chance lawmakers could make major decisions about Social Security—including benefit cuts or privatization—without much public scrutiny.
It’s a political window of opportunity, and potentially a dangerous one.
As you likely know, Social Security faces a long-term funding gap—not bankruptcy, as some would have you believe, but a mismatch between the money coming in and the benefits going out. The program isn’t going broke, but unless Congress acts, it will eventually fall short of the money needed to pay every dollar of benefits owed. That’s a real issue, which doesn't need the added drama of a manufactured bankruptcy crisis.
most valuable federal program>span class="xt0psk2">.
These are the issues at stake: Should people who earn millions pay Social Security taxes on more of their income, as the program's founders intended, instead of getting a tax break once they hit the income limit? Should you have to work longer before collecting benefits, even if you’re in a physically demanding job or can't find work? Should benefits be cut, even for people who’ve spent a lifetime paying into the system?
In a nutshell: Raise the cap, raise your retirement age, or cut your benefits. Or combine these approaches. These are the choices that could eventually become actual bills, put to actual votes in the House and Senate. A proposal has to make its way through Congress, win enough votes in both chambers, and then go to the president to be signed into law. Depending on what lawmakers put into a bill, the changes could affect the size of your retirement check, when you can collect it, and the benefits available to surviving spouses, children, and people with disabilities.
This is no time to look away. To understand how much we stand to lose, let’s recall why Social Security was created in the first place, how it helped build the American middle class, and why we should fight like hell to protect it.
The Poorhouse: Relic of the Past—or Our Future?
Before Social Security, there was another institution Americans knew all too well: the poorhouse.
Consider what happened to Lily Ingleston of New York in 1829. Lily was just 35, and her husband had skipped town, leaving her with nine children. Sick with typhus and unable to feed her kids, she turned to local authorities for help. They sent the whole family to the county poorhouse.
There, they were expected to work on the poorhouse farm. Refuse, and they could be thrown into solitary confinement and given nothing but bread and water.
Lily died three weeks after arriving. Within six months, three of her children were dead, too. The surviving younger ones were sent to live as indentured servants with different families in four different towns.
Tragedies like this unfolded all across America when the county poorhouse was the last resort for people who had fallen on hard times and had nowhere else to turn.
Social reformer Homer Folks called them “a disgraceful chapter” in American life. The sick, the disabled, the elderly, and destitute children were jammed together in these Dickensian warehouses, forced to live on watery gruel, without medical care, in harsh, unsanitary conditions. The idea was to deter people from coming rather than to provide support. When you checked in, you got an institutional uniform, like a prisoner, and your belongings were confiscated. You checked your independence and dignity at the door.
The Great Depression threw millions of families into this position. In that America, not so long ago, you could work hard your whole life, do everything right, and one run of bad luck could leave you depending on relatives, begging for charity, or facing the dreaded poorhouse just to survive.
This was the world Social Security was created to change.
In 1935, President Franklin Roosevelt and Congress created Social Security around the distinctly American idea of a shared bargain. Workers would contribute a small portion of their paychecks, employers would contribute an equal amount, and that money would help provide hard-working Americans a dependable income in retirement.
The concept was earned social insurance—a way for Americans to pool their resources against the uncertainties of life and provide a measure of security when people could no longer work. Over time, it expanded to protect surviving spouses and kids, as well as people with disabilities. The first person to receive a regular monthly Social Security retirement check was Ida May Fuller, a retired legal secretary in Vermont, who found a $22.54 check in her mailbox in January 1940.
Over time, Social Security became one of the cornerstones of the middle class. It was an American triumph: everyone got the upside. Retirees spent their money at grocery stores, pharmacies, restaurants, and local businesses. They helped their grandchildren go to college and stayed active in their communities. Social Security kept money flowing through towns and neighborhoods across the country.
The Economy Changed—and Social Security Got Short-Changed
As years passed, this story took an unfortunate turn. Social Security didn’t stop working—the checks kept coming, month after month, rain or shine, helping millions stay out of poverty. The problem was that the economy was transforming. Social Security is financed primarily through taxes on wages, with workers and employers sharing the cost.
But a growing share of America's economic gains was no longer going to workers.
It happened because powerful people made choices about how the American economy should work. Beginning in the 1970s, a political and corporate movement began pushing to change the rules, and over the next several decades, they pretty much got what they wanted. And they’d never been fond of Social Security.
It started with business leaders seeking greater influence in Washington. In 1971, corporate attorney Lewis Powell famously urged businesses to organize and get hold of public opinion, universities, courts, and politicians. The Business Roundtable formed in 1972, while think tanks like the Heritage Foundation and the Cato Institute promoted lower taxes, deregulation and limited government.
Politicians jumped aboard. President Jimmy Carter deregulated industries such as airlines, while Ronald Reagan expanded the movement through tax cuts, deregulation, and policies weakening organized labor. Major tax cuts followed in 1981 and 1986, and later administrations of both parties continued this economic approach.
The effects piled up. Companies moved production overseas, outsourced jobs, fought union organizing, and increasingly put shareholder returns ahead of workers' wages. Working people lost bargaining power and their paychecks lost purchasing power. Meanwhile, corporate executives and big shareholders got obscenely rich.
Americans were producing more wealth, but the people doing much of the work weren't invited to the party.
Which brings us back to Social Security. The people who designed the program couldn’t have anticipated just how dramatically the economy would change.
As noted recently at MarketWatch, a study by AARP found that in 1983, about 41 percent of the nation’s gross domestic product was subject to Social Security payroll taxes. By 2025, that share had dropped to 34 percent. AARP estimates that if the earlier share had been maintained, Social Security would have collected an additional $10.8 trillion between 1984 and 2034. According to its analysis, that additional revenue could have extended full benefit payments until 2059, rather than 2034.
Alas, that’s not what happened.
We Tax Work. How About Wealth?
There’s another important wrinkle. Social Security payroll taxes apply only up to an annual earnings ceiling. In 2026, that ceiling is $184,500. A worker earning $60,000 pays the tax on every dollar. But someone earning $2 million pays it only on the first $184,500.
Think about that. The nurse, teacher, mechanic, and restaurant worker pay Social Security taxes on all their wages. The person earning millions stops paying the tax on additional wages after reaching the ceiling.
Another problem in our top-heavy economy is that today, many of the richest don’t make most of their money from a paycheck. Their fortunes come from stocks, investments, capital gains, dividends, business ownership, and other forms of wealth that generally aren't subject to Social Security payroll taxes. A billionaire whose investments grow by hundreds of millions of dollars may pay nothing in Social Security taxes on those gains. Zilch. Elon Musk, for example, pays not a single penny into the program. That would be the same Musk who attacked the program through DOGE and mislead the public with specious claims about fraud.
Bottom line: our system taxes work but largely ignores wealth, so some of the people who have ridden high on America’s economy contribute little or nothing to its funding.
None of this is an accident. It's the result of policy choices that have favored the wealthy.
There are other pressures. Americans are living longer, the baby boom generation has retired, and fewer workers are supporting each retiree. But two factors get talked about far less: wages haven’t grown as quickly as program designers anticipated, and an increasingly large share of the nation's wealth isn’t subject to Social Security taxes in the first place.
So here we are with a funding gap that might never have happened if the economy and the tax system had evolved more fairly. And now we have to deal with it.
And you can bet that politicians from both parties who answer to the rich will be trying to cut benefits or make working people wait longer for the money they've earned.
There’s a Better Way to Protect Social Security
Some politicians and wealthy interests are dusting off the old saw that Social Security is supposedly unaffordable. This line has been recycled for decades, treating cuts to earned benefits as inevitable while ignoring the choices about wages, inequality, and taxation that helped create the program’s financial challenges.
There is a better way. The obvious move is to start by getting rid of the cap on earnings above $184,500 so that people earning gazillions pay Social Security taxes on all their wages, just as ordinary workers do. But we should also have a serious conversation about how to bring substantial investment income and other forms of extraordinary wealth into the financing of Social Security. That would require a carefully designed new contribution, with protections for ordinary retirement savings and middle-income households.
The principle is simple: People who earn their living through work shouldn't carry nearly the entire burden of financing retirement security while enormous fortunes generated through investments sit largely outside the system. We don't have to choose between protecting Social Security and protecting working Americans. We can make the system fairer, strengthen its finances, and make increased benefits possible for current and future generations.
But right now, it’s critical to watch politicians who say the right things but won’t level with the public about what they're actually prepared to do. They are legion.
President Trump has repeatedly said he won't cut benefits, yet the public still needs to see a credible plan. Democrats, too, have made protecting Social Security a central promise, but they must be equally clear about what the plan is and what changes they're willing to fight for.
Saying “I support Social Security” is easy, but explaining your plan and casting a vote for it is something else entirely.
Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) has been among those calling to “Scrap the Cap” on earnings above the current 2026 taxable maximum. He’s also proposed extending Social Security taxes to investments and certain business income above $250,000. His Social Security Expansion Act would increase benefits by $2,400 annually while strengthening the system’s long-term finances and ensuring that the richest fork over a fairer share.
Then there are groups like Majority Democrats, formed in 2025 as a hybrid PAC and super PAC to steer the Democratic Party away from progressive policies. Backed by members of Rupert Murdoch’s media-mogul family, it’s corporate-friendly politics tarted up as a Democratic rebrand. They are not to be trusted on Social Security. They’ll talk about protecting benefits while keeping cuts on the table, all wrapped in the familiar packaging of “moderation” and “fiscal responsibility.”
To be clear: raising the retirement age is a benefit cut, as is means-testing benefits and switching to a stingier inflation measure like chained CPI. These are cuts by stealth, buried in technical jargon and sold as “reform.” Over time they steadily shrink its purchasing power, leaving retirees further behind as the cost of living climbs. Don't be fooled.
Consider Rep. Jake Auchincloss (D-Mass.), chair of Majority Democrats. While styling himself a defender of Social Security, Auchincloss, a millionaire, has floated raising the retirement age. He’s also in favor of means-testing. Nobel laureate Joseph Stiglitz and other leading economists have long warned that means testing is a backdoor attempt to undermine the program. “We don’t means-test public education,” explained Stiglitz, “because we believe that we want people to have the same opportunities and we lose out on that with means-testing.” Means-testing erodes public support and fosters the illusion that somebody is getting a handout. Social Security is a safety net, not a handout to the needy.
Some Democrats are keen to reach across the aisle to make bipartisan “reform” deals, like Senator Tim Kaine (D-VA) and Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL), who put forth a proposal that could open the door to benefit cuts, raising the retirement age, or weaken the program. They are joined by Senators Bill Cassidy (R-LA), Thom Tillis (R-NC), John Cornyn (R-TX), and Alan Armstrong (R-OK).
Americans deserve better.
No politician should get a free pass here. Social Security belongs to the us, and the people meeting in Washington are its stewards, not its owners. The program embodies the values we care about, like hard work, fairness, shared responsibility, and the belief that people deserve dignity regardless of their wealth. It helped make the middle class possible by giving millions of families a foundation beneath which they were less likely to fall.
If America can generate stratospheric fortunes for a privileged few, surely it can afford economic security for the millions who built this country.