Transatlantic securitisation gap revisited: comparing EU and US securitisation architectures

This paper revisits the transatlantic gap in securitisation issuance. In comparing the securitisation frameworks in the European Union (EU) and United States, we adopt a granular approach, distinguishing between instrument types and considering the broader funding and risk transfer frameworks in which securitisation operates. We conclude that the apparent gap in terms of scale stems from methodological and structural differences in how securitisation is defined and measured across jurisdictions, rather than from a structurally weaker or less developed EU securitisation market. In particular, commonly cited comparisons of securitisation volumes often exclude covered bond issuance, despite covered bonds being a significant and longstanding component of asset-backed funding in the EU. As a result, measures of the transatlantic “securitisation gap” that focus solely on conventional securitisation may overstate the difference between EU and US market-based funding. When covered bond issuance is incorporated into the analysis, a more disaggregated picture emerges: over the past two decades, asset-backed funding activity has not been structurally one-sided but has instead exhibited shifting patterns over time, reflecting differences in market conditions and positions in the financial cycle. We introduce the concept of an asset mobilisation ratio to scale issuance by the size of each economy. From this perspective, transatlantic convergence appears to be ongoing, with the gap in issuance narrowing over time, although a meaningful difference in market scale remains. However, the persistence of this gap should not be viewed as evidence that the EU market is structurally underdeveloped relative to the US market. Direct quantitative comparisons are complicated by significant differences in market structures, funding channels, legal frameworks and institutional arrangements across jurisdictions. [...]